On his many visits to semiconductor factories and electric car plants, Germany’s Chancellor Olaf Scholz bangs the drum for an economy at the forefront of an industrial transformation.

But the picture painted by business leaders and experts is less rosy, predicting hard times to come for Europe’s largest economy.

Having dipped into recession at the beginning of the year, Germany looks set to finish the year in the red – and at the back of the pack among its eurozone competitors.

The government is the only one still predicting Gross Domestic Product (GDP) will grow this year, while the leading economic institutes and the IMF are looking at a drop of 0.2 to 0.4%.

Soaring inflation, painful interest rate rises, a sluggish recovery in its key export market China, and high energy costs are all weighing on activity.

The malaise might be more than temporary, some analysts warn.

“We currently see the country faced by a growing mountain of challenges,” said Siegfried Russwurm, head of the influential BDI industry lobby.

A growing number of businesses, including small and midsize companies, are working on “moving part of their activities out of Germany,” Russwurm said at the BDI’s annual conference.

In the newspapers, the specter of Germany as the “sick man of Europe” is back, harking back to the period before 2000 when the country struggled to compete in international markets and faced high levels of unemployment.

New Era

Scholz, who became chancellor in late 2021, prefers to point to a different economic era.

In an interview with German media in March, he said the push to achieve climate neutrality by 2045 would bring back “levels of growth like in the 1950s and 1960s,” the age of West Germany’s postwar “economic miracle.”

For the Social Democrat chancellor, the massive spending needed to install new wind turbines, build electric vehicles, make steel production less polluting, or produce heat pumps will create a virtuous economic circle.

But the vision of a new economic golden age thanks to the transition to green energy leaves some experts skeptical.

The switchover will first see billions of euros sunk into “replacing the existing stock” of fossil-fuel technologies with renewable ones “with significantly elevated costs,” Russwurm said.

“That will not lead to extra economic growth in the short term.”

“We will only reap the reward of this investment in the distant future when we have effectively managed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions,” Timo Wollmershaeuser of the economic think-tank the Ifo Institute told German media this week.

Relatively sluggish growth of less than one percent awaits Germany over the next few years, the country’s leading economic institutes predict.

“Growth could be significantly weaker over this decade than in the 2010s, years of supposed prosperity,” said Marcel Fratzscher, head of the DIW think-tank.

No longer attractive?

The country is likewise held back by structural weaknesses that are stymying economic performance: slow bureaucracy, low levels of digitalization and an aging population that could lead to labor shortages.

“If the population sinks, GDP will not grow either,” Wollmershaeuser said.

With the economy heavily reliant on manufacturing, Germany looks to suffer from energy costs that have risen since the war in Ukraine, even though they have fallen from their early peaks.

Russia was long the main gas source for Germany, supplying huge volumes at relatively low prices to the country’s biggest industrial groups.

“Energy costs, labor shortages, bureaucracy – for us, producing in Germany is no longer attractive,” Ingeborg Neumann, head of the German textile industry association, said at the BDI event.