SPOILER ALERT: “Yellowstone” – Realistic Themes and Over-the-Top Depictions

Introduction

This article discusses general themes from the first five seasons of the hit TV show “Yellowstone.” The heart of the show revolves around the Dutton family’s work protecting, preserving, and making money from their ranch. With ongoing writers and actors strikes affecting the production of scripted shows, CBS is bolstering its fall schedule by rerunning “Yellowstone.” In honor of the show’s broadcast network premiere, Haber Tusba spoke with Jessie Jarvis, a third-generation Idaho rancher, to gain insight into what’s realistic in the show and what’s over the top.

Realistic: Family farming (and family drama)

The Dutton family’s dynamics and dysfunction portrayed on the show reflect the challenges faced by family-owned ranching operations. Working alongside family members every day can create tension, especially when living on the business premises. Unlike owning a regular store, ranching requires constant attention and makes it difficult to switch off. Holidays can be particularly challenging for ranching families.

Land encroachment

The show accurately depicts the issue of land encroachment faced by rural areas due to increasing populations. The desire to move out of cities and into smaller towns, combined with the effects of COVID-19, has led to more people buying up land. However, this poses a challenge in terms of feeding a growing population while preserving resources.

State government’s focus on ranching

In Idaho, ranching holds significant importance, with the governor and many state legislators coming from ranching families. Strong organizations like the Idaho Cattle Association represent the interests of ranching families and maintain close relationships with government officials, addressing industry issues promptly.

The clothes

The show accurately portrays Western industry brands in the characters’ clothing choices. Brands like Kimes Ranch, American Hat, and Greeley Hat, commonly worn by real ranchers, are featured on the show. The attention to detail in the costumes reflects the creator’s commitment to authenticity.

Real-life rodeo athletes

The show features real rodeo athletes performing reining patterns on horseback. These athletes are professionals in their respective sports and provide an authentic representation of the equestrian world. The show also portrays the horses realistically, acknowledging their roles as competitors.

Pride in the land

The Duttons’ appreciation for the land, their cattle, and their work resonates with real-life ranchers. Despite the show’s depiction of wealth, ranching is not financially lucrative. Ranchers are driven by their love for the lifestyle, the opportunity to raise their families, and the fulfillment of continuing a heritage deeply rooted in the nation’s history.

Not so realistic: The equipment

The Duttons’ wealth and the high-end equipment they possess do not accurately reflect the majority of farms and ranches in America. While some ranches may have access to top-of-the-line vehicles and trailers, it is not representative of the average family farming and ranching operation. Investor-owned ranches are the exception, not the norm.

Violence and profanity

The show’s depiction of violence and crude language is far from realistic. The frequency of violent incidents, including shootings, is exaggerated for dramatic effect. Similarly, the profanity used by the characters is excessive and not reflective of real-life conversations on ranches.

Conclusion

“Yellowstone” captures many realistic aspects of ranching life, including family dynamics, land encroachment, and the pride ranchers have in their work. However, certain elements like the characters’ wealth, extravagant equipment, and exaggerated violence and profanity deviate from reality. Despite these discrepancies, the show provides entertainment and an opportunity for viewers to immerse themselves in the world of ranching.